| Year | Sponsor | Reg. Season | Playoffs | Manager |
| 1951 | Kiwanis | 7-4 | Aaron Lefkowitz | |
| 1952 | Kiwanis | 5-13 | Bob Smith | |
| 1953 | Kiwanis | 11-5 | Bob Smith | |
| 1954 | Kiwanis | 10-7 | Bob Smith | |
| 1955 | Kiwanis | 8-9 | Ed Wragge | |
| 1956 | Kiwanis | Unknown | Pete Mulry | |
| 1957 | Kiwanis | 9-11 | Pete Mulry | |
| 1958 | Kiwanis | 9-10 | Pete Mulry | |
| 1959 | Kiwanis | 15-5 | 0-1 | Pete Mulry |
| 1960 | Kiwanis | 12-5 | 2-1 | Ted Ryder |
| 1961 | Kiwanis | 12-5 | 1-2 | Ted Ryder |
| 1962 | Kiwanis | 3-13 | Ted Ryder | |
| 1963 | Kiwanis | 8-7 | Ted Ryder | |
| 1964 | Kiwanis | 7-8 | Ted Ryder | |
| 1965 | Kiwanis | 11-4 | Pat Amato | |
| 1966 | Kiwanis | Unknown | 2-0 | Pat Amato |
| 1967 | Kiwanis | 8-6 | Pat Amato | |
| 1968 | Kiwanis | 8-6 | Pat Amato | |
| 1969 | Kiwanis | 7-8 | Pat Amato | |
| 1970 | Kiwanis | Unknown | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1971 | Kiwanis | Unknown | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1972 | Kiwanis | Unknown | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1973 | Kiwanis | 12-3 | 0-2 | Pete DeLuise |
| 1974 | Kiwanis | Unknown | 0-2 | Pete DeLuise |
| 1975 | Kiwanis | 6-9 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1976 | Kiwanis | 3-12 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1977 | Kiwanis | 8-8 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1978 | Kiwanis | 10-6 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1979 | Kiwanis | 14-2 | 0-2 | Bill Brooks |
| 1980 | Kiwanis | 15-2 | 2-0 | Bill Brooks |
| 1981 | Kiwanis | 12-4 | 2-0 | Bill Brooks |
| 1982 | Kiwanis | 13-3 | 2-0 | Pete DeLuise |
| 1983 | Kiwanis | 6-10 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1984 | Kiwanis | 6-9 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1985 | Kiwanis | 5-10 | Pete DeLuise | |
| 1986 | Kiwanis | 10-5 | 0-2 | Pete DeLuise |
| 1987 | Kiwanis | 12-4 | John Russo | |
| 1988 | Kiwanis | 6-10 | John Russo | |
| 1989 | Kiwanis | 12-4 | John Russo | |
| 1990 | Kiwanis | 9-7 | Tom Clare | |
| 1991 | Kiwanis | 12-4 | 0-2 | Joe Slavik |
| 1992 | Kiwanis | 12-4 | 2-2 | Joe Slavik |
| 1993 | Kiwanis | 15-1 | 3-0 | Joe Slavik |
| 1994 | Kiwanis | 2-14 | Joe Slavik | |
| 1995 | Kiwanis | 4-12 | Joe Slavik | |
| 1996 | Kiwanis | 5-11 | Joe Slavik | |
| 1997 | Kiwanis | 6-10 | George Dunn | |
| 1998 | Kiwanis | 9-7 | 0-1 | George Dunn |
| 1999 | Kiwanis | 10-7 | 2-1 | George Dunn |
| 2000 | Kiwanis | 13-3 | 1-1 | George Dunn |
| 2001 | Kiwanis | 9-7 | 1-1 | Tom McCallum |
| 2002 | Kiwanis | 2-14 | Tom McCallum | |
| 2003 | Kiwanis | 6-10 | Tom McCallum | |
| 2004 | Kiwanis | 13-3 | 0-1 | Tom McCallum |
| 2005 | A.W. Van Winkle & Co. | 14-2 | 0-1 | Tom McCallum |
| 2006 | A.W. Van Winkle & Co. | 15-1 | 2-0 | Tom McCallum |
| 2007 | A.W. Van Winkle & Co. | 12-4 | 2-0 | Bob Miskura |
| 2008 | A.W. Van Winkle & Co. | 0-16 | John Sasso | |
| 2009 | A.W. Van Winkle & Co. | 0-16 | John Sasso |